Make firms fund their cleanup

Publish cleanup costs, funds set aside and work done. Have an outside expert check the figures.

Our planUpdated:

Our argument

A firm should pay to clean up the harm it leaves. A promise to pay later is not cash set aside today. We want cleanup plans and funds checked in public before the risk grows.

What must change

Publish cleanup costs, funds set aside and work done. Have an outside expert check the figures.

What a win looks like

Credible cleanup plans and enough secure funds, with progress that people can check.

Public cost

We have not yet priced this ask for the public purse. Any public aid must be priced before we seek funds for it.

The evidence

E-E01

Alberta’s auditor put oil-sands mine cleanup costs at $51.9 billion. The security held was $1.8 billion. Security means funds or pledges held to help cover the bill.

Limits: These are total cost estimates, not a bill paid each year. The gap is not proven debt for the public. It leaves out other wells and the total cost for pipelines.

E-E02

Federal pipeline rules use trusts, credit letters or bonds to back future cleanup.

Limits: Some trust funds build up over time. Check each firm’s costs, funds, payment dates and exceptions. This rule alone does not show that all costs are covered.

Studies and notes

What we need to check

Keep mines, wells and pipelines in separate ledgers. Compare estimated costs, funds held, work done and who bears any gap.

Updates

— Case opened with our argument, our ask and the facts still to check.

— The cleanup bill and the cash held are different.

Back this front: Energy & nature

This button backs the whole front shown below. It does not turn on emails.

Support totals are not available right now.

Each email counts once per cause. This does not sign a petition. Your name and email stay private. Only the total is public.

More cases on this front

See the whole agenda ↗